We did not expect the extent to which Israel violates international laws to oppress the Palestinian people. Our exposure to East Jerusalem and the West Bank was overwhelming, one which traumatised us. However, even though we experienced that the Palestinians live in open-air prisons, they were still able to inspire us with their dignity and their commitment for a just peace based on human dignity for both themselves and the Israelis. “We want more than human rights,” they told us, “we want our human dignity and reconciliation”.
These are the first words from a media statement issued by twelve South African Christian leaders who visited the occupied state of Palestine from 2 – 9 December 2012.
The delegation included the country’s heads of the Methodist and the Uniting Presbyterian Churches, the Secretary General of the Evangelical Alliance, the Vice Moderator of the Dutch Reformed Church and a representative of South African youth.
Rev Moss Nthla, Secretary General of The Evangelical Alliance of South Africa and Chairperson of Kairos Southern Africa and Dr Braam Hanekom, Vice Moderator of the Dutch Reformed Church, addressing an audience of Palestinian Christians in Bethlehem
The statement continued as follows:
Being South African, it felt like walking into another apartheid ambush. We witnessed violations of the international human rights law and the international humanitarian law on so many levels – the multiple house demolitions, the discriminatory legal system, the daily intimidation, the Apartheid Wall and its associated regime of restrictions on movement and access, the damage to olive groves, the imprisonment of a large percentage of Palestinians including children, the confiscation of water and land, the closure of previously bustling streets and businesses, separate pavements and a system whereby the colour of Palestinian vehicles’ number plates restrict them to certain roads.
Our visit was undertaken in direct response to the Palestinian Christians’ invitation to come and see for ourselves what their circumstances are. We heard from Christians how they have experienced a political and an identity catastrophe (the Nakba) since 1948 when the State of Israel was declared and 750 000 Palestinians became refugees. Moreover, they experience a theological catastrophe as Christianity is being used to justify the oppression of the indigenous Palestinian people.
What we have discerned is in alignment with what the Palestinian Christians propose in their document called “A Moment of Truth. A word of faith, hope and love from the heart of the Palestinian suffering.” This urgent appeal to the international community proposes resistance to Israel’s occupation as an act of love.
We affirm the right to security, self-determination and dignity for both the Palestinians and the Israelis. Real security is only possible through the exercise of justice. We are conscious how a literal reading of the Bible, one where the Israel of the Old Testament is confused with the State of Israel, can result in the oppression of people. We confirm that the crisis in the Holy Land is in essence not a religious conflict, but a political crisis brought about by the violation of international law. As South Africans we believe we have a moral obligation to speak up and to stand with the oppressed. We do not want to side against the Israelis, but we do want to uphold international law and fight against any form of injustice.
We support the Palestinians’ call for non-violent resistance. They ask for responsible tourism whereby pilgrims who visit Bethlehem and the Old City of Jerusalem also visit Palestinian Christians. They ask the world for economic, cultural and other forms of boycott, divestment and sanctions – a strategy that helped to end apartheid in South Africa. We believe that maximum pressure must be put on Israel to abide by international law. This should be done on the basis of “equality and sharing, not on superiority, negation of the other or aggression, using the pretext of fear and security” as stated in the Palestinian document “A Moment of Truth”.
We went on a guided tour by a Jewish Rabbi (previously from Canada) and we had intense discussions with him over dinner in Jerusalem. From him we did not hear the message of reconciliation or that both peoples were created in the image of God and have the right to dignified lives. He talked a lot, but he did not answer our questions.
The Vice Moderator of the Dutch Reformed Church, Dr Braam Hanekom who was part of our delegation, emphatically stated:
“It was a tremendous privilege to visit Palestine in this time of Advent. I am more convinced than before that the non-violent alternative of faith, hope and love that the Palestinian Christians show us is the way forward.”
Our statement concludes as follows:
Whilst we remain intensely and painfully aware of the weaknesses and the prevailing injustices in our own South African context, we are inspired to work against these and other injustices. In these weeks leading up to Christmas we want to show our full solidarity with all those who suffer in the Holy land where Christ was born.
- Bishop Zipho Siwa, Presiding Bishop of the Methodist Church in Southern Africa
- Dr Jerry Pillay, General Secretary of the Uniting Presbyterian Church in Southern Africa and President of the World Communion of Reformed Churches
- Rev Moss Nthla, Secretary General of The Evangelical Alliance of South Africa and Chairperson of Kairos Southern Africa
- Dr Braam Hanekom, Vice Moderator of the Dutch Reformed Church
- Ms Nonhlanhla Shezi, President of the Anglican Youth of Southern Africa
- Ms Theresa Ramphomane, Coordinator of the SACC Women’s Ecumenical Conference
- Ms Nobuntu Madwe, General President of the Women’s Manyano (Union) of the Methodist Church of South Africa
- Fr Michael Deeb, coordinator of the Justice and Peace Department of the Southern African Catholic Bishops’ Conference
- Fr Zweli Tom, Anglican Priest and Secretary General of the Nelson Mandela Bay Consultation of Christian Churches
- Nonqaba Esther Dlula, Eastern Cape Anglican Church
- Dr Stiaan van der Merwe, Kairos Southern Africa
- Ms Marthie Momberg, Kairos Southern Africa
Jerusalem, 8 December 2012.
We do not take sides between countries, but we are not impartial when it comes to the upholding of international law and human rights. We are just as concerned about the psyche of the oppressor as we are about the devastating effects of denying people dignity. Israel’s occupation of Palestine must end.
8 thoughts on “Bold statement by South African clergy on their return from occupied Palestine”
Thanks Marthie for your link “Bold statement of S.A. church delegation on their return from occupied Palestine. I wonder if you are related to the deceased Jannie Momberg? We did meet him a few times, my wife worked for the Dutch Foreign Affairs Dept. Kindest regards,Joop & Ans Jansen.
p.s.keep up your wonderful blog with great links.
Dear Joop & Ans, it is great to hear from you and I hope that I don’t disappoint you by saying that I am not related to the late Jannie Momberg other than staying in his home town and knowing some of his descendants.
How many Israelis did you talk to? That the church should be involved in this one-sided PR exercise for the Palestinian Authority reflects poorly on the participants. How many rockets were fired into Israeli territory during their visit I wonder?
For any assessment or statement to be fair and instructive on the true situation in this conflict one must have engaged both sides and afforded each side to state their position and respond to any criticism. What was the motive of the visit and how credible is this report back? To me, this was another opportunity missed by Kairos who have set themselves up as flag carriers rather than peace seeking Christian mediators.
Thank you so much for sharing this statement, Marthie. The international and local media in an overwhelming way publish pro-Israel stories which often draw a caricature of the Palestinians and their fight for freedom and a better future. So many Christians like yourself and, I would suppose, other members of the delegation have visited Israel before and are well acquainted with the challenges Israeli Jews face. But it most certainly was high time that a South African delegation of this kind took the trouble of actually hearing and seeing firsthand [and on behalf of those you represented] something of the injustice Palestinians have to endure.
Johan, I disagree with you on the press coverage issue: local media is biased and not towards Israel. I’m not saying Israel is blameless but just that your statement is not confirmed by hard facts. Worse still and closer to home there is absolutely minimal coverage of Christians in Northern Nigeria. Have you read any statements in condemnation from the Church? Deafening silence. It seems we are cherry picking conflict situations to champion