Never Again – unconditionally

As Jews, with our own painful history of oppression, we are compelled to speak out against human rights violations committed by the State of Israel – in our name – against the Palestinian people.

These are the first words of a group of South African Jews in their public statement in the Mail & Guardian of 14 December 2012. They recognise not only their own wounds and humanity…


…but also those of others:

The temptation is to speak in muffled tones about an issue such as the right of the people of Palestine… yet we would be less than human if we did so”

 – Nelson R. Mandela

2009 (2) Berlyn 022A Holocaust memorial site in Berlin, Germany.

Their statement continued as follows:

We note that the South African Jewish Board of Deputies (SAJBD) together with the South African Zionist Federation (SAZF) recently met with the South African Presidency and other politicians. We also note, with great concern, that the SAJBD and SAZF’s assertion that they represent and speak on behalf of all Jewish South Africans, particularly when it comes to Palestine-Israel.


Let us be clear, the SAJBD and SAZF’s position of supporting Israel at all costs does not represent us. We also appeal to the SAJBD and SAZF to respect one of the hallmarks of Judaism: respectful debate amongst those who hold divergent viewpoints. The SAJBD and SAZF’s position on Israel, and attempts to stifle opposing voices that speak out against Israel, is morally untenable.

The Jewish community is neither homogeneous nor monolithic.  There is a growing number of Jews, in South Africa and around the world, who are organising to form alternative spaces and who unconditionally oppose Israeli policies and practices that shamefully privilege Jews over the indigenous Palestinian people.  In this vein, we support the non-violent campaign of applying Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) against Israel until it abides by international law and respects basic human rights [see].

We are encouraged that our South African government is joining those countries that are taking a clear stance against Israel’s violations of international law and its acts of violence against the Palestinian people [see this City Press newspaper article]. We also welcome and support our Department of Trade and Industry’s initiative to prevent the false labelling of Israeli settlement products. We hope that the ANC and the SA Government goes further and completely bans Israeli settlement products. Israeli settlements are in clear violation of international law and seriously undermine any chance of negotiations and a just peace.

Such positions as those recently taken by our government against Israeli violence and violations of international law, in fact, serve to affirm a proud Jewish tradition of respect for justice and human rights; regardless of race, religion or creed. Such positions connect us to our fellow humanity.

We humbly – and sadly – acknowledge that our voices may not be the dominant ones in our community, but neither were Dietrich Bonnhoefer’s in Nazi Germany nor Beyers Naude’s, Antjie Krog’s, Braam Fischer’s and Joe Slovo’s in Apartheid South Africa.

Our individual consciences, our Jewish tradition and our painful history compel us to declare to the SAJBD, SAZF and to the Israeli government that we will continue to speak out and take a stand for justice and human rights.  Taking such a stand is in the very interests of being Jewish. For when we proclaim “Never Again”, we should mean “Never Again”, unconditionally, and to any human being – including the Palestinians.

Issued by Alan Horwitz for StopTheJNF, a campaign initiated by a group of Jewish South Africans committed to justice and rights for the Palestinian people and Jewish Israelis.

2009 (2) Berlyn 011

I took this photo in the Jewish Museum, Berlin.  The windows reflect the harrowing, unsettling reality of Jews during World War II.

Never Again – but unconditionally.

5 thoughts on “Never Again – unconditionally

  1. Nic de Jager says:

    In total agreement. Our aggressive Zionist brothers are in danger of alienating themselves from the world. And it tends to tar all other reasonable people of Jewish origin with the same brush. Bibi and his policies are disastrous for Israel and the world as a whole.


    • Do you really know these people Charl? Do you know that although both Israel and Palestine experience and perform acts of violence, the “overall right of an occupied population to resist a foreign military occupation, including through use of arms against military targets, is recognised as lawful under international law”? (Bennis 2012:3). (don’t get me wrong, I do NOT advocate for violence). Are you familiar with Israel’s systemic, institutionalised oppression of the Palestinians that violates international law on a daily basis? Look at the United Nations website: Shouldn’t we as South Africans be concerned about yet another form of apartheid?


      • Gideon says:

        So you believe Apartheid does not exist there, so then why do you support the BDS? Who say that apartheid does exist there? Another form of apartheid means true apartheid does not exist. By this comment you have made many of your posts worthless…and bigoted. The truth always comes out. This time you have proven yourself to be on the wrong side and you proved it to yourself with your own words.


  2. Monique Buckner says:

    Gideon, there are dozens of laws which discriminate against non-Jews both within Israel and in the occupied areas- see Adalah organisaton’s summaries of these laws such as citzenship. The Russell Tribunal on Palestine held in Cape Town, November 2011 and consisting of international law experts, found this to be quite true. If something is a form of racim, it is racism. If something is a form of apartheid, it is apartheid. Apartheid and racism (and other types of bigotry) materialise in many forms and South African and Israeli aparhteid don’t have to be identical for Israeli apartheid to be called thus.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s